- cross-posted to:
- palestine@lemmy.ml
- usa@lemmy.ml
- cross-posted to:
- palestine@lemmy.ml
- usa@lemmy.ml
Coming under fire from the left for the glaring contradiction of providing military assistance to a state that is perpetrating an active genocide, AOC issued a statement claiming her vote was about protecting civilians. AOC’s statement is absolute crap. The Iron Dome is not used for defending, it’s used to facilitate constant attacks. In an article for Jewish Currents titled “Iron Dome Is Not a Defensive System,” Dylan Saba explains:
“‘In theory, a weapon like Iron Dome could be used only defensively. But in practice it doesn’t work that way,’ analyst Nathan Thrall told Jewish Currents. ‘Iron Dome facilitates greater Israeli offensive measures, because it lowers the perceived cost to Israel of escalating or extending or initiating attacks.’ In other words, while the Iron Dome may prevent the deaths of Israeli non-combatants, it has made it easier for Israel to engage in deadly operations that take Palestinian lives.”
The Iron Dome isn’t for protecting civilians, it’s for protecting the Israeli regime from deterrence. We see this in the comfort the regime displays in waging constant military violence on its neighbors knowing they can’t retaliate. That’s why Israel cut a ceasefire deal with Iran so fast.
Iran’s advanced missiles can’t be reliably stopped by the Iron Dome, so Iran was able to smash Israel and force it to cease its unprovoked aggressions. If Israel had had a missile defense system which could casually swat those missiles out of the sky at a high rate of success, Israel would still be bombing Iran today, and would continue doing so until Tehran looked like Gaza. Israel’s war-horny population would have supported this, because they’d have no skin in the game.
This is why people laugh at the extreme left. Splitters!
If you’re laughing at the position “genocide is bad” and consider it “extreme”, then you’re a Nazi
Except the take wasn’t “genocide is bad,” it was “let’s all turn on one of the most prominent left-leaning American politicians in Congress and pretend she supports genocide because of a single nuanced vote that doesn’t actually have any functional effect.” It’s fine to say you disagree with the vote. It’s fine to say you wish there were more politicians further left than her. But to vilify her on this one meaningless scenario is shooting yourself in the foot unless you really want the conservatives, neoliberals, and corporate Democrats to remain in power forever.
Genocide denier
Quote me where I denied it. Genocide is absolutely going on. That doesn’t mean AOC is solely responsible for it. Nuance is a thing.
Denying the democrats role in it is still Genocide denial.
Selective quoting level maximum.